We already accept that some transactions should be off limits. The difficult question is whether buying sexual access belongs among them.
Begin with what the law actually says
Nevada is the only U.S. state with a legal, licensed-brothel exception to the general prohibition on prostitution. The other 49 states prohibit buying sex. Even in Nevada, the exception is limited: state law prohibits purchasing sex outside a licensed house of prostitution, and local restrictions also apply.1 2 That comparison concerns buyers; it does not mean every state treats people selling sex the same way.
The international picture is more varied. UNAIDS reports that 167 countries criminalize some aspect of sex work. That category includes different activities and does not establish that 167 countries—or most countries—specifically criminalize the purchase of sex.3 Some jurisdictions target buyers, others penalize sellers or third parties, and others permit or decriminalize consensual adult transactions.
A legal majority is a starting point for discussion, not proof of moral correctness. Nor should we assume that every legislature adopted its law for the same reason. The argument below is our case for the boundary, rather than a claim about a single historical motive shared by 49 states.
Consent matters. So do the conditions surrounding it.
The strongest argument for allowing the purchase of sex is personal autonomy: adults should generally be free to make choices about their own bodies. That argument deserves a serious answer. Consensual adult sex work and trafficking are not identical, and describing them as interchangeable obscures both agency and coercion.
Our concern is that a transaction can be formally agreed to while taking advantage of another person's severely limited choices. Poverty, dependency, threats, and lack of alternatives can affect bargaining power. These possibilities do not prove that every person selling sex lacks agency. They do require us to ask what a buyer should be permitted to purchase when the consequences fall so intimately on another person.
What does a market teach us to expect?
A market does more than match individual choices; it establishes expectations about what money can obtain. We believe sexual intimacy should remain grounded in freely given, continuing consent, rather than a commercial expectation of access. Payment can never create an entitlement to override a person's boundaries or refusal.
The analogy to votes, children, or organs is about the limits of markets, not a claim that these transactions are legally or morally identical. The common question is whether willingness to pay is enough to justify what is being purchased. Our answer is no.
Why some laws focus on the buyer
Sweden's approach prohibits purchasing sexual services while not criminalizing the person selling them for that act. The Swedish Gender Equality Agency describes its rationale in terms of gender equality, exploitation, and responsibility for demand. It also emphasizes that legislation must be accompanied by social support.4 This is one explicit policy rationale; it should not be presented as the explanation for every country's law.
Our position favors deterring the purchase of sex while treating people in the sex trade with dignity, listening to their experiences, and supporting safety and practical alternatives. A conviction that people are priceless should lead to housing, healthcare, protection from abuse, and opportunities—not contempt.
A protective law must be judged by its effects
The policy debate is real. UNAIDS supports decriminalization and warns that punitive laws can obstruct access to HIV services.5 Supporters of buyer-focused laws must take such concerns seriously, including whether enforcement makes it harder to seek help or report violence. Moral intention alone does not establish that a particular law works.
We believe society should reject a commercial entitlement to sexual access. To honor that principle, policy must protect people in practice, measure outcomes, and respond honestly when enforcement causes harm. The worth of a person cannot depend on agreement with our position.
What should money never entitle one person to expect from another?
Sources & further reading · Reviewed October 17, 2026
- Associated Press: Nevada's legal-brothel exception — reporting on the U.S. legal landscape.
- Nevada Revised Statutes, § 201.354 — the restriction on customers outside licensed houses of prostitution.
- UNAIDS: Decriminalization global overview — the count concerns criminalization of any aspect of sex work, not only purchasing.
- Swedish Gender Equality Agency: The Swedish sex purchase law — the government's account of its policy rationale.
- UNAIDS: Save lives—decriminalize — a public-health argument for a different policy approach.